Technology

Race realism is not realistic and it is not good science

The resurgence of narratives claiming innate intellectual hierarchies based on racial identity has sparked intense debate within the global scientific community and beyond. These viewpoints, often cloaked in the language of "race science" or "race realism," have migrated from the periphery of academic discourse into the mainstream political arena, finding expression in high-level policy discussions and public statements by world leaders. Critics, including geneticists, evolutionary biologists, and sociologists, argue that these claims are not only scientifically unfounded but are also being leveraged to dismantle social equality initiatives and justify discriminatory government policies.

The political climate surrounding these claims reached a fever pitch at the World Economic Forum in Davos, where former US President Donald Trump characterized Somali populations as having low IQs. This rhetoric mirrors previous comments by Donald Trump Jr. regarding Haitian migrants in 2024. These statements coincide with administrative actions taken by the Trump government to revoke protected statuses for Somali and Haitian migrants, highlighting the tangible, real-world impact of pseudoscientific beliefs on immigration policy and human rights.

The Myth of Genetic Determinism

At the heart of the "race realist" movement is the concept of hereditarianism—the belief that genetic differences are the primary drivers of behavioral and cognitive variances between human populations. However, this position is diametrically opposed to the consensus held by modern genetics. Since the pioneering work of evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin in the 1970s, it has been established that genetic variation within any given human population is significantly greater than the variation between populations.

The human genome does not support the categorization of people into discrete racial groups based on intelligence or behavioral capacity. While specific physiological traits—such as skin pigmentation, hair texture, and localized metabolic adaptations like lactose persistence—do vary geographically, these are environmental adaptations. They do not correlate with a consistent, innate "racial" blueprint. Modern genomic research, including the study of ancient DNA, demonstrates that human history is defined by constant migration, interbreeding, and genetic mixing. The concept of "pure bloodlines" or distinct racial clusters is a social construct that fails to align with the complex, non-linear reality of human evolution.

Methodological Failures in IQ Research

The primary evidence cited by proponents of race science usually centers on national IQ databases. Scholars have repeatedly debunked these databases as methodologically flawed, noting that IQ tests are heavily influenced by environmental factors, including access to quality education, nutrition, healthcare, and economic stability. Because these tests were often developed in Western contexts, they struggle to accurately measure cognitive ability across culturally and educationally diverse populations.

“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science

Furthermore, research indicates a phenomenon known as the "Flynn effect," which documents the steady, significant rise in IQ scores over the 20th and 21st centuries. Because this increase occurred over a span too short for genetic evolution to take hold, it serves as definitive proof that IQ is highly malleable and largely determined by environmental conditions. Despite this, race scientists continue to rely on "just-so" stories, such as the "cold winters theory," which posits that colder climates necessitated higher intelligence. This theory lacks empirical support, ignoring the vast, diverse environmental challenges faced by populations in tropical and equatorial regions, which required equal, if not greater, cognitive adaptability.

Historical Context and the Persistence of Eugenics

To understand the current climate, one must look at the 20th-century history of eugenics. During the early 1900s, biologically deterministic views of race were used to justify forced sterilization programs in the United States and the genocidal policies of the Nazi regime in Germany. Following the atrocities of World War II, the scientific community largely rejected race science, recognizing its role in facilitating systemic human rights abuses.

However, a network of committed individuals sought to maintain these ideologies. The Pioneer Fund, established in the 1930s by a textile magnate to advocate for race-based research and oppose desegregation, played a pivotal role in funding journals like Mankind Quarterly. This infrastructure has evolved over decades, transitioning into modern iterations like the Human Diversity Foundation and Polygenic Scores LLC. This network operates as a self-sustaining ecosystem—a "community project," as described by historian of psychology Andrew Winston—complete with its own funding channels, mentorship programs, and, most crucially, a system of peer-review gatekeeping in certain academic subfields.

The Role of Academic Gatekeeping

The survival of race science in academic journals is largely confined to specific, non-mainstream publications. Most high-impact genetics and evolutionary biology journals maintain rigorous peer-review standards that effectively filter out flawed hereditarian studies. However, some journals in the fields of psychology, intelligence research, and evolutionary psychology have historically been more permissive.

The editorial policies of journals like Intelligence have faced scrutiny for allowing the publication of controversial work under the guise of "academic freedom." Critics argue that this provides a veneer of legitimacy to pseudoscience. While institutions like University College London have taken steps to investigate and block the hosting of "secret" eugenics conferences on their campuses, the network has adapted by shifting its output to evolutionary psychology circles and alternative media platforms like Aporia magazine.

Financial Backing and Media Amplification

The persistence of race science is not merely an academic issue; it is a well-funded political endeavor. Investigative reporting by Hope not Hate exposed that an international network of race scientists received significant financial support from figures such as US businessman Andrew Conru. Although public pressure has caused some donors to withdraw, the infrastructure remains active.

“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science

The digital landscape has further accelerated the spread of these ideas. Social media platforms, particularly X (formerly Twitter), have become primary vectors for the dissemination of race-realist propaganda. By reframing their content as "scientific" or "controversial truth-telling," these actors bypass traditional media gatekeepers to reach a mass audience. This digital framing turns academic fringe theories into populist narratives that influence political discourse and voter sentiment.

Implications for Society and Science

The propagation of race science carries profound risks. When scientific authority is co-opted to support political ideologies of superiority or inferiority, it threatens the integrity of scientific inquiry and undermines the principles of equality upon which democratic institutions are built. The use of flawed genetic arguments to justify policy decisions—such as the cessation of protected status for vulnerable migrant groups—demonstrates that the "race realism" movement is actively shaping the lives of millions.

The scientific community remains largely unified in the view that cognitively, human groups are the same. Behavioral diversity is a product of our species’ unique ability to adapt to environments through culture and social learning, rather than distinct, evolved psychological traits. By ignoring decades of rigorous research in anthropology, psychology, and biology, race scientists promote a view of humanity that is not only inaccurate but socially destructive.

As the debate continues, the burden of responsibility lies with academic institutions, journal editors, and the broader public to distinguish between rigorous, evidence-based science and the persistent, ideological pseudoscience of the past. Academic freedom is a cornerstone of inquiry, but it is not a shield for methodologically unsound, exclusionary, and historically debunked propaganda. The future of public discourse depends on the ability to recognize that when "race realism" is subjected to the scrutiny of legitimate, modern science, it is exposed as a construct that fails the most basic tests of reality.

Related Articles

Back to top button