Chadd Sayers: Former Australian bowler rejects Pat Cummins’ claims about ‘Sandpapergate’: ‘Everyone knew what was going on’

The revelations from the former Test cricketer, delivered in a candid interview with SEN Radio, have reignited one of the most controversial chapters in the history of Australian cricket. As the sporting world continues to grapple with the long-term fallout of the 2018 Newlands incident, Sayers’ testimony provides a granular, if unsettling, look into the internal culture of the Australian squad during that period. By aligning himself with similar claims previously made by Usman Khawaja, Sayers has effectively deepened the rift between current leadership and those who occupied the dressing room during the ill-fated South African tour.
The Newlands Incident: A Retrospective Timeline
To understand the weight of Sayers’ recent comments, it is necessary to revisit the sequence of events that shocked the cricketing world in March 2018. During the third Test against South Africa in Cape Town, television cameras captured Cameron Bancroft attempting to alter the condition of the ball using a piece of yellow sandpaper.
- March 24, 2018: The third day of the third Test. Bancroft is caught on camera attempting to hide the object down his trousers.
- March 25, 2018: Cricket Australia launches an immediate investigation. Captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner step down from their leadership roles.
- March 28, 2018: Smith, Warner, and Bancroft are sent home. Cricket Australia imposes heavy suspensions: Smith and Warner for 12 months, and Bancroft for nine months.
- 2018–2026: The narrative remains contested. While official reports focused on the "trio" of conspirators, persistent rumors suggested a broader culture of complicity.
- November 2026: Chadd Sayers, who served as 12th man during that Test, breaks his silence, asserting that the knowledge of the tampering was shared among the entire playing XI.
The Mechanics of the Conspiracy
Sayers, who earned his sole Test cap in the final match of that series, provided a sobering account of how the team navigated the illicit operation. According to his testimony, the use of sandpaper was not a spontaneous decision but the result of deliberate, team-wide communication. He alleges that discussions regarding methods to induce reverse swing took place openly within the confines of the dressing room.
"It was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in change-rooms of how we were going to get the ball to reverse and what was going to be used," Sayers stated. Perhaps most damning is his description of the logistics. He claims he was tasked with retrieving the offending item from Bancroft while performing his duties as the 12th man. This suggests a level of logistical coordination that contradicts the narrative of a rogue operation led by a select few.
Sayers’ admission—that he was a young player trying to "fit in" and maintain his place in a high-pressure environment—highlights the sociological pressures of elite sports. He noted that the demographic of the team was relatively young and, at the time, they lacked a full appreciation for the catastrophic reputational damage the incident would ultimately inflict.
The Clash of Narratives: Sayers versus Cummins
The current Australian captain, Pat Cummins, has been resolute in his defense of the team’s integrity, describing previous allegations from Usman Khawaja as "utter nonsense." Cummins’ stance has consistently been that the scandal was limited to the individuals already punished, and that the wider team was not privy to the plan.
Sayers, however, rejects this, insisting that he is "comfortable" standing by his recollection. He specifically disputes the timeline of the aftermath, claiming that for 60 to 90 minutes following the incident, the team engaged in intensive discussions about who would step forward and accept the fall. This contradicts the perception that the players were unaware until the broadcast images were shown. For Sayers, the burden of keeping this secret has been significant. He described the process of "tiptoeing around" the truth for eight years as a psychological strain, expressing a sense of relief that the details are finally emerging.
Statistical Context and the Culture of Reverse Swing
The focus on reverse swing during the 2018 series was not coincidental. In the years leading up to the scandal, reverse swing had become the "holy grail" of bowling tactics for teams playing in dry, abrasive conditions like those found in South Africa.
Statistical analysis of Australian bowling performance during that era showed a marked increase in effectiveness when the ball was roughed up. However, the use of external objects is a direct violation of Law 41.3 of the Laws of Cricket, which governs the condition of the ball. The reliance on such tactics—whether driven by the coaching staff or the players—suggests a "win-at-all-costs" mentality that had permeated the Australian dressing room. The subsequent cultural review conducted by Simon Longstaff for Cricket Australia in late 2018 identified exactly this: a culture where the pursuit of victory had overshadowed the importance of the spirit of the game.
Implications for Australian Cricket
The timing of these revelations is particularly sensitive for Cricket Australia. As the team prepares for high-profile international fixtures, the resurfacing of the sandpaper scandal threatens to destabilize the current dressing room. The tension between former teammates who hold conflicting accounts of the past creates a public relations challenge for the national governing body.
There are three primary implications of Sayers’ testimony:
- Credibility of Leadership: If the entire team was aware, the official narrative maintained by Cricket Australia for nearly a decade is fundamentally flawed. This raises questions about the transparency of the 2018 investigation and whether further disciplinary measures should have been taken at the time.
- Psychological Impact on Players: The "omertà" or code of silence described by Sayers reflects the immense pressure on fringe players to conform. This serves as a cautionary tale for sports management regarding the dangers of insular team cultures.
- The "Ashes" Legacy: With the next Ashes series on the horizon, the focus will inevitably shift back to the integrity of the Australian side. Critics will likely use these admissions to question the sportsmanship of the current squad, despite the vast majority of the 2018 personnel having since retired.
Analysis: A Culture of Complicity?
From an objective standpoint, the discrepancy between the accounts of Sayers and the official Cricket Australia narrative suggests a systemic failure in reporting mechanisms. In elite sports, the "dressing room culture" is often insulated from external scrutiny, creating an environment where players feel that their primary loyalty is to each other rather than to the regulations of the sport.
The fact that a 12th man—a player on the periphery—was directly involved in the disposal of the sandpaper indicates that the plan required the cooperation of more than just the captain, vice-captain, and the fielder in question. If the information was common knowledge, it implies that the silence was a collective decision. Whether this was born out of fear of retribution, misplaced loyalty, or an genuine belief that they were acting in the interest of the team, it points to a significant failure in the ethical governance of the squad at that time.
Future Outlook
As the cricketing world moves forward, the "Sandpapergate" saga remains a scar on the sport’s history. Chadd Sayers’ decision to speak out adds another layer of complexity to an already tangled narrative. While he may be dismissed by some as a disgruntled former player, the consistency of his account with that of Usman Khawaja makes it increasingly difficult for the sport’s governing bodies to dismiss these claims as mere speculation.
The broader lesson for professional sports organizations is clear: the cost of a cover-up is almost always higher than the cost of the initial error. By attempting to contain the scandal to a few individuals in 2018, the institution may have inadvertently ensured that the truth would continue to leak out, piece by piece, for years to come. For now, the Australian cricket team must contend with the reality that, even eight years later, the ghosts of Cape Town have not been laid to rest. The sport must now decide whether to launch a secondary, more comprehensive inquiry to finally close this chapter, or to accept that the full truth of 2018 will remain a point of contention between those who were there and those who choose to remember it differently.







